🐛 [firebase_auth] Version 4.5.0 depends on firebase_auth_web ^5.4.0, which depends on intl ^0.17.0

[carloshpb]

Bug report

Resolving dependencies...
Because no versions of firebase_auth match >4.5.0 <5.0.0 and firebase_auth 4.5.0 depends on firebase_auth_web ^5.4.0, firebase_auth ^4.5.0 requires firebase_auth_web ^5.4.0.
Because firebase_auth_web 5.4.0 depends on intl ^0.17.0 and no versions of firebase_auth_web match >5.4.0 <6.0.0, firebase_auth_web ^5.4.0 requires intl ^0.17.0.
Thus, firebase_auth ^4.5.0 requires intl ^0.17.0.
So, because __ depends on both firebase_auth ^4.5.0 and intl ^0.18.1, version solving failed.

Steps to reproduce

Steps to reproduce the behavior:

1. Simply try to updated firebase_auth while having intl version to 0.18.1, which is the one for Dart 3

Expected behavior

Shouldn't have conflict with intl version 0.18.1

[Patrick386]

Same issue.
Because no versions of firebase_auth match >4.5.0 <5.0.0 and firebase_auth 4.5.0 depends on firebase_auth_web ^5.4.0, firebase_auth ^4.5.0 requires firebase_auth_web ^5.4.0.
Because firebase_auth_web 5.4.0 depends on intl ^0.17.0 and no versions of firebase_auth_web match >5.4.0 <6.0.0, firebase_auth_web ^5.4.0 requires intl ^0.17.0.
Thus, firebase_auth ^4.5.0 requires intl ^0.17.0.
So, because __ depends on both intl ^0.18.0 and firebase_auth ^4.5.0, version solving failed.

[mdddj]

dependency_overrides:
  intl: 0.18.0

Solved my problem

[BirjuVachhani]

This doesn't solve the problem for me unfortunately. I use wiredash and it creates conflicts with this for some reason.

Because wiredash >=1.0.0-alpha.2 depends on flutter_localizations from sdk which depends on intl 0.18.0, wiredash >=1.0.0-alpha.2 requires intl 0.18.0.
Because firebase_auth_web 5.4.0 depends on intl ^0.17.0 and no versions of firebase_auth_web match >5.4.0 <6.0.0, firebase_auth_web ^5.4.0 requires intl ^0.17.0.
Thus, wiredash >=1.0.0-alpha.2 is incompatible with firebase_auth_web ^5.4.0.
And because firebase_auth 4.5.0 depends on firebase_auth_web ^5.4.0 and no versions of firebase_auth match >4.5.0 <5.0.0, wiredash >=1.0.0-alpha.2 is incompatible with firebase_auth ^4.5.0.
So, because codelessly depends on both firebase_auth ^4.5.0 and wiredash ^1.6.0, version solving failed.

[immadisairaj]

Maybe to add some more context on firebase_ui_auth as well that I am currently facing after upgrading all my firebase packages.

Because no versions of firebase_ui_auth match >1.3.0 <2.0.0 and firebase_ui_auth 1.3.0 depends on flutter_localizations from sdk, firebase_ui_auth ^1.3.0 requires flutter_localizations from sdk.
And because every version of flutter_localizations from sdk depends on intl 0.18.0, firebase_ui_auth ^1.3.0 requires intl 0.18.0.
And because firebase_auth_web 5.4.0 depends on intl ^0.17.0 and no versions of firebase_auth_web match >5.4.0 <6.0.0, firebase_ui_auth ^1.3.0 is incompatible with firebase_auth_web ^5.4.0.
And because firebase_auth 4.5.0 depends on firebase_auth_web ^5.4.0 and no versions of firebase_auth match >4.5.0 <5.0.0, firebase_ui_auth ^1.3.0 is incompatible with firebase_auth ^4.5.0.

Packages (and their versions) I am using

cloud_firestore: ^4.6.0
firebase_auth: ^4.5.0
firebase_core: ^2.11.0
firebase_ui_auth: ^1.3.0
firebase_ui_firestore: ^1.4.0
firebase_ui_oauth_google: ^1.1.5

[rayk]

dependency_overrides:
  intl: 0.18.0

Solved my problem

This will work if you don't depend on flutter_localizations and SDK is at 3.0.0. So the problem for any working off stable with an intl app.

[immadisairaj]

Yeah, that solved.. and the thing regarding flutter_localizations I solved it by adding it to the pubspec.

dependencies:
  # for localizations (firebase_ui_auth uses)
  flutter_localizations:
      sdk: flutter

# for rest
dependency_overrides:
  intl: 0.18.0

[krunalSutariya]

dependency_overrides:
  intl: 0.18.0

Solved my problem

[darshankawar]

To everyone facing this issue, there's already a similar open issue describing the case: #10199
And most recent comment indicates a fix is in sight: #10199 (comment) so please follow-up in the linked issue for further updates. I'll close this as a duplicate. If anyone disagrees, write in comments and I'll reopen it.

[BirjuVachhani]

Yeah, that solved.. and the thing regarding flutter_localizations I solved it by adding it to the pubspec.

dependencies:
  # for localizations (firebase_ui_auth uses)
  flutter_localizations:
      sdk: flutter

# for rest
dependency_overrides:
  intl: 0.18.0

This worked for me. However, my project uses melos and one of the deployed sub-packages uses older version of intl (0.17.0) and for some reason, melos doesn't seem to work with it. I had to manually create pubspec_overrides.yaml.

[carloshpb]

Nevermind guys. New updated was just launched right now. Just update your firebase_auth to 4.6.0, and let intl be 1.8.0, that it'll work out.