gh-91162: Support splitting of unpacked arbitrary-length tuple over TypeVar and TypeVarTuple parameters (alt) (GH-93412)

For example:

  A[T, *Ts][*tuple[int, ...]] -> A[int, *tuple[int, ...]]
  A[*Ts, T][*tuple[int, ...]] -> A[*tuple[int, ...], int]

Author: serhiy-storchaka

Include/internal/pycore_global_strings.h

@@ -202,6 +202,7 @@ struct _Py_global_strings {
         STRUCT_FOR_ID(__truediv__)
         STRUCT_FOR_ID(__trunc__)
         STRUCT_FOR_ID(__typing_is_unpacked_typevartuple__)
+        STRUCT_FOR_ID(__typing_prepare_subst__)
         STRUCT_FOR_ID(__typing_subst__)
         STRUCT_FOR_ID(__typing_unpacked_tuple_args__)
         STRUCT_FOR_ID(__warningregistry__)

Include/internal/pycore_runtime_init.h

@@ -824,6 +824,7 @@ extern "C" {
                 INIT_ID(__truediv__), \
                 INIT_ID(__trunc__), \
                 INIT_ID(__typing_is_unpacked_typevartuple__), \
+                INIT_ID(__typing_prepare_subst__), \
                 INIT_ID(__typing_subst__), \
                 INIT_ID(__typing_unpacked_tuple_args__), \
                 INIT_ID(__warningregistry__), \

Lib/test/test_typing.py

@@ -753,14 +753,11 @@ class C(Generic[*Ts]): pass
             ('generic[*Ts]',                           '[*tuple_type[int]]',                             'generic[int]'),
             ('generic[*Ts]',                           '[*tuple_type[*Ts]]',                             'generic[*Ts]'),
             ('generic[*Ts]',                           '[*tuple_type[int, str]]',                        'generic[int, str]'),
+            ('generic[*Ts]',                           '[str, *tuple_type[int, ...], bool]',             'generic[str, *tuple_type[int, ...], bool]'),
             ('generic[*Ts]',                           '[tuple_type[int, ...]]',                         'generic[tuple_type[int, ...]]'),
             ('generic[*Ts]',                           '[tuple_type[int, ...], tuple_type[str, ...]]',   'generic[tuple_type[int, ...], tuple_type[str, ...]]'),
             ('generic[*Ts]',                           '[*tuple_type[int, ...]]',                        'generic[*tuple_type[int, ...]]'),
-
-            # Technically, multiple unpackings are forbidden by PEP 646, but we
-            # choose to be less restrictive at runtime, to allow folks room
-            # to experiment. So all three of these should be valid.
-            ('generic[*Ts]',                           '[*tuple_type[int, ...], *tuple_type[str, ...]]', 'generic[*tuple_type[int, ...], *tuple_type[str, ...]]'),
+            ('generic[*Ts]',                           '[*tuple_type[int, ...], *tuple_type[str, ...]]', 'TypeError'),
 
             ('generic[*Ts]',                           '[*Ts]',                                          'generic[*Ts]'),
             ('generic[*Ts]',                           '[T, *Ts]',                                       'generic[T, *Ts]'),
@@ -772,15 +769,21 @@ class C(Generic[*Ts]): pass
             ('generic[list[T], *Ts]',                  '[int, str]',                                     'generic[list[int], str]'),
             ('generic[list[T], *Ts]',                  '[int, str, bool]',                               'generic[list[int], str, bool]'),
 
-            ('generic[T, *Ts]',                        '[*tuple[int, ...]]',                             'TypeError'),  # Should be generic[int, *tuple[int, ...]]
-
             ('generic[*Ts, T]',                        '[int]',                                          'generic[int]'),
             ('generic[*Ts, T]',                        '[int, str]',                                     'generic[int, str]'),
             ('generic[*Ts, T]',                        '[int, str, bool]',                               'generic[int, str, bool]'),
             ('generic[*Ts, list[T]]',                  '[int]',                                          'generic[list[int]]'),
             ('generic[*Ts, list[T]]',                  '[int, str]',                                     'generic[int, list[str]]'),
             ('generic[*Ts, list[T]]',                  '[int, str, bool]',                               'generic[int, str, list[bool]]'),
 
+            ('generic[T, *Ts]',                        '[*tuple_type[int, ...]]',                        'generic[int, *tuple_type[int, ...]]'),
+            ('generic[*Ts, T]',                        '[*tuple_type[int, ...]]',                        'generic[*tuple_type[int, ...], int]'),
+            ('generic[T1, *Ts, T2]',                   '[*tuple_type[int, ...]]',                        'generic[int, *tuple_type[int, ...], int]'),
+            ('generic[T, str, *Ts]',                   '[*tuple_type[int, ...]]',                        'generic[int, str, *tuple_type[int, ...]]'),
+            ('generic[*Ts, str, T]',                   '[*tuple_type[int, ...]]',                        'generic[*tuple_type[int, ...], str, int]'),
+            ('generic[list[T], *Ts]',                  '[*tuple_type[int, ...]]',                        'generic[list[int], *tuple_type[int, ...]]'),
+            ('generic[*Ts, list[T]]',                  '[*tuple_type[int, ...]]',                        'generic[*tuple_type[int, ...], list[int]]'),
+
             ('generic[T, *tuple_type[int, ...]]',      '[str]',                                          'generic[str, *tuple_type[int, ...]]'),
             ('generic[T1, T2, *tuple_type[int, ...]]', '[str, bool]',                                    'generic[str, bool, *tuple_type[int, ...]]'),
             ('generic[T1, *tuple_type[int, ...], T2]', '[str, bool]',                                    'generic[str, *tuple_type[int, ...], bool]'),

Lib/typing.py

@@ -1065,6 +1065,42 @@ def __repr__(self):
     def __typing_subst__(self, arg):
         raise TypeError("Substitution of bare TypeVarTuple is not supported")
 
+    def __typing_prepare_subst__(self, alias, args):
+        params = alias.__parameters__
+        typevartuple_index = params.index(self)
+        for param in enumerate(params[typevartuple_index + 1:]):
+            if isinstance(param, TypeVarTuple):
+                raise TypeError(f"More than one TypeVarTuple parameter in {alias}")
+
+        alen = len(args)
+        plen = len(params)
+        left = typevartuple_index
+        right = plen - typevartuple_index - 1
+        var_tuple_index = None
+        fillarg = None
+        for k, arg in enumerate(args):
+            if not (isinstance(arg, type) and not isinstance(arg, GenericAlias)):
+                subargs = getattr(arg, '__typing_unpacked_tuple_args__', None)
+                if subargs and len(subargs) == 2 and subargs[-1] is ...:
+                    if var_tuple_index is not None:
+                        raise TypeError("More than one unpacked arbitrary-length tuple argument")
+                    var_tuple_index = k
+                    fillarg = subargs[0]
+        if var_tuple_index is not None:
+            left = min(left, var_tuple_index)
+            right = min(right, alen - var_tuple_index - 1)
+        elif left + right > alen:
+            raise TypeError(f"Too few arguments for {alias};"
+                            f" actual {alen}, expected at least {plen-1}")
+
+        return (
+            *args[:left],
+            *([fillarg]*(typevartuple_index - left)),
+            tuple(args[left: alen - right]),
+            *([fillarg]*(plen - right - left - typevartuple_index - 1)),
+            *args[alen - right:],
+        )
+
 
 class ParamSpecArgs(_Final, _Immutable, _root=True):
     """The args for a ParamSpec object.
@@ -1184,6 +1220,8 @@ def __typing_subst__(self, arg):
                             f"ParamSpec, or Concatenate. Got {arg}")
         return arg
 
+    def __typing_prepare_subst__(self, alias, args):
+        return _prepare_paramspec_params(alias, args)
 
 def _is_dunder(attr):
     return attr.startswith('__') and attr.endswith('__')
@@ -1255,44 +1293,6 @@ def __dir__(self):
                 + [attr for attr in dir(self.__origin__) if not _is_dunder(attr)]))
 
 
-def _is_unpacked_tuple(x: Any) -> bool:
-    # Is `x` something like `*tuple[int]` or `*tuple[int, ...]`?
-    if not isinstance(x, _UnpackGenericAlias):
-        return False
-    # Alright, `x` is `Unpack[something]`.
-
-    # `x` will always have `__args__`, because Unpack[] and Unpack[()]
-    # aren't legal.
-    unpacked_type = x.__args__[0]
-
-    return getattr(unpacked_type, '__origin__', None) is tuple
-
-
-def _is_unpacked_arbitrary_length_tuple(x: Any) -> bool:
-    if not _is_unpacked_tuple(x):
-        return False
-    unpacked_tuple = x.__args__[0]
-
-    if not hasattr(unpacked_tuple, '__args__'):
-        # It's `Unpack[tuple]`. We can't make any assumptions about the length
-        # of the tuple, so it's effectively an arbitrary-length tuple.
-        return True
-
-    tuple_args = unpacked_tuple.__args__
-    if not tuple_args:
-        # It's `Unpack[tuple[()]]`.
-        return False
-
-    last_arg = tuple_args[-1]
-    if last_arg is Ellipsis:
-        # It's `Unpack[tuple[something, ...]]`, which is arbitrary-length.
-        return True
-
-    # If the arguments didn't end with an ellipsis, then it's not an
-    # arbitrary-length tuple.
-    return False
-
-
 # Special typing constructs Union, Optional, Generic, Callable and Tuple
 # use three special attributes for internal bookkeeping of generic types:
 # * __parameters__ is a tuple of unique free type parameters of a generic
@@ -1385,10 +1385,6 @@ def __getitem__(self, args):
             args = (args,)
         args = tuple(_type_convert(p) for p in args)
         args = _unpack_args(args)
-        if (self._paramspec_tvars
-                and any(isinstance(t, ParamSpec) for t in self.__parameters__)):
-            args = _prepare_paramspec_params(self, args)
-
         new_args = self._determine_new_args(args)
         r = self.copy_with(new_args)
         return r
@@ -1410,30 +1406,16 @@ def _determine_new_args(self, args):
 
         params = self.__parameters__
         # In the example above, this would be {T3: str}
-        new_arg_by_param = {}
-        typevartuple_index = None
-        for i, param in enumerate(params):
-            if isinstance(param, TypeVarTuple):
-                if typevartuple_index is not None:
-                    raise TypeError(f"More than one TypeVarTuple parameter in {self}")
-                typevartuple_index = i
-
+        for param in params:
+            prepare = getattr(param, '__typing_prepare_subst__', None)
+            if prepare is not None:
+                args = prepare(self, args)
         alen = len(args)
         plen = len(params)
-        if typevartuple_index is not None:
-            i = typevartuple_index
-            j = alen - (plen - i - 1)
-            if j < i:
-                raise TypeError(f"Too few arguments for {self};"
-                                f" actual {alen}, expected at least {plen-1}")
-            new_arg_by_param.update(zip(params[:i], args[:i]))
-            new_arg_by_param[params[i]] = tuple(args[i: j])
-            new_arg_by_param.update(zip(params[i + 1:], args[j:]))
-        else:
-            if alen != plen:
-                raise TypeError(f"Too {'many' if alen > plen else 'few'} arguments for {self};"
-                                f" actual {alen}, expected {plen}")
-            new_arg_by_param.update(zip(params, args))
+        if alen != plen:
+            raise TypeError(f"Too {'many' if alen > plen else 'few'} arguments for {self};"
+                            f" actual {alen}, expected {plen}")
+        new_arg_by_param = dict(zip(params, args))
 
         new_args = []
         for old_arg in self.__args__:

Misc/NEWS.d/next/Library/2022-06-01-11-24-13.gh-issue-91162.NxvU_u.rst

@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
+Support splitting of unpacked arbitrary-length tuple over ``TypeVar`` and
+``TypeVarTuple`` parameters. For example:
+
+* ``A[T, *Ts][*tuple[int, ...]]`` -> ``A[int, *tuple[int, ...]]``
+* ``A[*Ts, T][*tuple[int, ...]]`` -> ``A[*tuple[int, ...], int]``

Objects/genericaliasobject.c

@@ -269,7 +269,7 @@ _Py_make_parameters(PyObject *args)
    a non-empty tuple, return a new reference to obj. */
 static PyObject *
 subs_tvars(PyObject *obj, PyObject *params,
-           PyObject **argitems, Py_ssize_t nargs, Py_ssize_t varparam)
+           PyObject **argitems, Py_ssize_t nargs)
 {
     PyObject *subparams;
     if (_PyObject_LookupAttr(obj, &_Py_ID(__parameters__), &subparams) < 0) {
@@ -283,28 +283,28 @@ subs_tvars(PyObject *obj, PyObject *params,
             Py_DECREF(subparams);
             return NULL;
         }
-        for (Py_ssize_t i = 0, j = 0; i < nsubargs; ++i) {
+        Py_ssize_t j = 0;
+        for (Py_ssize_t i = 0; i < nsubargs; ++i) {
             PyObject *arg = PyTuple_GET_ITEM(subparams, i);
             Py_ssize_t iparam = tuple_index(params, nparams, arg);
-            if (iparam == varparam) {
-                j = tuple_extend(&subargs, j,
-                                 argitems + iparam, nargs - nparams + 1);
-                if (j < 0) {
-                    return NULL;
-                }
-            }
-            else {
-                if (iparam >= 0) {
-                    if (iparam > varparam) {
-                        iparam += nargs - nparams;
+            if (iparam >= 0) {
+                PyObject *param = PyTuple_GET_ITEM(params, iparam);
+                arg = argitems[iparam];
+                if (Py_TYPE(param)->tp_iter && PyTuple_Check(arg)) {  // TypeVarTuple
+                    j = tuple_extend(&subargs, j,
+                                    &PyTuple_GET_ITEM(arg, 0),
+                                    PyTuple_GET_SIZE(arg));
+                    if (j < 0) {
+                        return NULL;
                     }
-                    arg = argitems[iparam];
+                    continue;
                 }
-                Py_INCREF(arg);
-                PyTuple_SET_ITEM(subargs, j, arg);
-                j++;
             }
+            Py_INCREF(arg);
+            PyTuple_SET_ITEM(subargs, j, arg);
+            j++;
         }
+        assert(j == PyTuple_GET_SIZE(subargs));
 
         obj = PyObject_GetItem(obj, subargs);
 
@@ -409,39 +409,37 @@ _Py_subs_parameters(PyObject *self, PyObject *args, PyObject *parameters, PyObje
                             self);
     }
     item = _unpack_args(item);
-    int is_tuple = PyTuple_Check(item);
-    Py_ssize_t nitems = is_tuple ? PyTuple_GET_SIZE(item) : 1;
-    PyObject **argitems = is_tuple ? &PyTuple_GET_ITEM(item, 0) : &item;
-    Py_ssize_t varparam = nparams;
     for (Py_ssize_t i = 0; i < nparams; i++) {
         PyObject *param = PyTuple_GET_ITEM(parameters, i);
-        if (Py_TYPE(param)->tp_iter) {  // TypeVarTuple
-            if (varparam < nparams) {
-                Py_DECREF(item);
-                return PyErr_Format(PyExc_TypeError,
-                                    "More than one TypeVarTuple parameter in %S",
-                                    self);
-            }
-            varparam = i;
-        }
-    }
-    if (varparam < nparams) {
-        if (nitems < nparams - 1) {
+        PyObject *prepare, *tmp;
+        if (_PyObject_LookupAttr(param, &_Py_ID(__typing_prepare_subst__), &prepare) < 0) {
             Py_DECREF(item);
-            return PyErr_Format(PyExc_TypeError,
-                                "Too few arguments for %R",
-                                self);
+            return NULL;
         }
-    }
-    else {
-        if (nitems != nparams) {
-            Py_DECREF(item);
-            return PyErr_Format(PyExc_TypeError,
-                                "Too %s arguments for %R; actual %zd, expected %zd",
-                                nitems > nparams ? "many" : "few",
-                                self, nitems, nparams);
+        if (prepare && prepare != Py_None) {
+            if (PyTuple_Check(item)) {
+                tmp = PyObject_CallFunction(prepare, "OO", self, item);
+            }
+            else {
+                tmp = PyObject_CallFunction(prepare, "O(O)", self, item);
+            }
+            Py_DECREF(prepare);
+            Py_SETREF(item, tmp);
+            if (item == NULL) {
+                return NULL;
+            }
         }
     }
+    int is_tuple = PyTuple_Check(item);
+    Py_ssize_t nitems = is_tuple ? PyTuple_GET_SIZE(item) : 1;
+    PyObject **argitems = is_tuple ? &PyTuple_GET_ITEM(item, 0) : &item;
+    if (nitems != nparams) {
+        Py_DECREF(item);
+        return PyErr_Format(PyExc_TypeError,
+                            "Too %s arguments for %R; actual %zd, expected %zd",
+                            nitems > nparams ? "many" : "few",
+                            self, nitems, nparams);
+    }
     /* Replace all type variables (specified by parameters)
        with corresponding values specified by argitems.
         t = list[T];          t[int]      -> newargs = [int]
@@ -471,22 +469,11 @@ _Py_subs_parameters(PyObject *self, PyObject *args, PyObject *parameters, PyObje
         if (subst) {
             Py_ssize_t iparam = tuple_index(parameters, nparams, arg);
             assert(iparam >= 0);
-            if (iparam == varparam) {
-                Py_DECREF(subst);
-                Py_DECREF(newargs);
-                Py_DECREF(item);
-                PyErr_SetString(PyExc_TypeError,
-                        "Substitution of bare TypeVarTuple is not supported");
-                return NULL;
-            }
-            if (iparam > varparam) {
-                iparam += nitems - nparams;
-            }
             arg = PyObject_CallOneArg(subst, argitems[iparam]);
             Py_DECREF(subst);
         }
         else {
-            arg = subs_tvars(arg, parameters, argitems, nitems, varparam);
+            arg = subs_tvars(arg, parameters, argitems, nitems);
         }
         if (arg == NULL) {
             Py_DECREF(newargs);